NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Extra Creamy Round Lipstick - Cocoa (With Peach Undertones)

This is my absolute favorite lippie since I can’t get BECCA’s “sugar” anymore. This (shade “rea”) is a near perfect dupe. It’s the PERFECT nude for me (I’m light w/cool, pink undertones). This is the closest dupe I’ve found for “sugar” (colourpop lippie stix & liner in “oh snap” is a very close second if anyone else is looking). I’m going to try to attach some photos w/more accurate swatches because this is NOT peach like the pic looks at all. My only complaint is that this doesn’t have staying power. It’s very creamy and hydrating, so it can have a pass for that, but if you’re going to eat or drink, be prepared to touch up every few minutes. The best lip liner I’ve found to go w/this is Colourpop’s “Ashton” lip liner. I have about every shade of NYX liners and none of them match as well as “Ashton” for me personally (this combo in photo). Now I just have to find this lipstick again..the search goes on. Disclaimer-I’m not a model or photographer in any way, just wanted to show more accurate color. This is not peachy at all.

This is recommended as a dupe for MAC's twig and it is amazing! I love the color!

Love the color of this lipstick! The photo does not do it justice. The lipstick is also very creamy and moisturizing. This color is violet ray. I have gotten a lot of compliments on this lipstick when I wear it. I was afraid I wouldn’t be able to find it again. But was very happy to find it on Amazon. This lipstick goes on very smoothly. Because it is so creamy and moisturizing, it really doesn’t last If you should happen to eat anything. But other than that, it stays nicely.

Creamiest lipstick. Treat it gently, the tube can break if you put pressure on it.

Sighhhhh. I was really excited to try this; was looking for a MAC Blankety dupe and saw NYX Thalia but thought it would be too purple for me. This seemed like a more neutral alternative.For those of you who have searched for swatches of this color, you'll know that IT NEVER LOOKS THE SAME in ANY picture. I saw Aubrey from Youtube (fafinettex3) had swatched these on her blog. She was the only person who has similar coloring to me who posted swatches so I hoped for the pale nude result she has in her picture.This was way to light for me (NC45) and I can't wear it alone. I would describe this as a chocolate milk color. It is an opaque, milky beige void of pink. I like mixing this color with other lipsticks or using it as a highlight. It pulled grey on my lips when worn alone. Very good formula, just not my color.

My husband ordered some tubes of this lipstick for me in the color “strawberry milk.” This seller sent us the WRONG color and now will not let us return them, even though they’re unused, still in the packaging.This is the seller’s mistake, not ours. Considering that we paid DOUBLE what this lipstick is worth and what it sells for everywhere else, I really hope they resolve this so we don’t have to open a case against them.My rating for the lipstick itself would be a 4. I’ve purchased it in person in the past and I loved the color. The only issue I’ve had is that the stick melts easily. Sometimes the stick literally just melts and falls off. But the color is so pretty that I keep trying to find it in stock. It’s the best dupe of my favorite high end lipstick I’ve been able to find.

Perfect red and goes on smoothly.

WOW! Whodda thunk such an inexpensive drugstore lipstick could deliver a great “POP” of color! I love this NYX Extra Creamy Lipstick In Chaos, ( Strawberry Pink). I’ve found that (almost) any lippie w/strawberry, watermelon or cranberry in the description has an 80% chance of working for me. It is beautifully shiny w/out being sticky. It did not transfer to my teeth, has a beautiful sheen w/out feeling gloppy or tacky like a gloss & my abs fav feature is the slightly blue undertone that make my teeth look so white. I did take off a few stars for longevity; def not a matte, ladies & gents. But I’ve a habit of pressing my lips together, so I do reapply a lot. Others may not experience this issue. I did find applying my Mac lip erase lip balm/primer helped w/staying power.. AND most NYX pro lipsticks have a clear little square at the base tube showing you exactly what the color@ is...because that’s ACTUALLY LIPSTICK IN THAT LITTLE SQUARE. It takes quite a bit of Herculean strength to pop that sucker off, but then you have a little pot o lipstick to get your pinkie Becoming nmessily pigmented as you dab on your lips..This is a refreshing change of pace for my wallet; I typ wear Ch Tillbury, Chanel, Rituel or Vapour. Lastly, excuse my freckles in pics but I think they represent the color well. I’m “Whasian” (Asian American) w/neutral undertones.