Growth: From Microorganisms to Megacities (Mit Press)

thanks!!

Vaclav Smil retains his ability to separate the kernals of economic knowledge from the dross of pedestrian analysis.

In fact, this guy writes a lot of books in this style. There's an incredible amount of raw facts and there is still good support for the theory underneath whatever his topic is.

I've only read the preface and about two chapters so far. This book is fairly dense. I've found it rewarding so far, but I knocked off two stars because the writing is extremely complicated and almost pretentious for what it's trying to convey.At times, entire pages read like a rambling lecture from one of your college elective classes. There are sprinkles of interesting facts and observations with a huge number of citations, but the author almost comes across as a drunk fool. He doesn't write with a purpose. I found myself reading entire pages of rather dense material, where a single sentence goes on and on for at least 4 or more lines. There are many passages where there are no real "takeaways". There are sentences that could be ripped apart or stripped out entirely and the main idea explained in six or seven words without losing detail.I don't want to accuse the author of anything, and I'll admit he excessively provides citations. But I gotta say – this book could be half its size if the author cut the bullshit. The complex writing is a delusion of grandeur. The reader is not better off by wasting time on these puzzles.

Smil looks again at the extent of growth at all scales of life. An excellent summary if what growth entails and what it means. Does the growth of non-organic institutions resemble organic biological growth. Smil thinks so.

Types of exponential in nature, population, energy sources or systems, and the factors for growth are described very precisely and broadly in this book. One type of exponential growth which is now in plateau form would be carbon uptake by oceans and rainforests. New conservation and ecosystem design projects can try to turn the "S" to a new exponential growth phase, even though this will be expensive for some countries.New types of energy systems like pumped-hydro energy storage can achieve exponential growth in many of the mountainous countries. Solar thermal also has yet to see very strong exponential growth as most new solar is the photovoltaic type. Prof. Smil's books are very good for a precise understanding of our challenges.

If this book had come out when I was 12, I would have memorized it. It's got all the gee-whiz facts on the biggest, fastest, thickest, heaviest, strongest, whatever. I'm still adolescent enough to have devoured every page of it, but the adult in me kept asking "So what?" Outside of the occasional caution that we can't grow everything forever, there isn't much by way of conclusions here. It's a great reference but not a great read. Two points may give you some idea. First, he celebrates and duly gives all the numbers for the enormous explosion of information that's out there, but he doesn't bother to say that almost all of the increase is in things like online bank accounts, names of customers at shoe stores, and other stuff of no significance except to the immediate needs of the person posting it. Meanwhile, the countless bits of vitally important information about ecosystems and survival that were held among traditional and small-scale cultures are being lost at an appalling rate. In terms of actually useful information, we are losing far too much. Second, Smil duly celebrates on p. 499 “all machines and gadgets that make running a household incomparably less onerous that [sic, for than] a century ago”--well, OK, but as a field anthropologist I have spent seven years of my life without them, or without most of them, often without even electricity, let alone running water, and those were the happiest years of my life. The problem with modern machine civilization is that all those conveniences are always breaking down and needing expensive and difficult repairs. Yet I can't escape--I can't live now without a car, computers, etc. We have locked ourselves into a totally unsustainable world of "growth"--is it in the end like that other unchecked and uncontrolled growth known as cancer?

I have been reading Smil books for about a decade now, and 'Growth' attempts to stimulate thought in the educated reader (I think the book's information is accessible to a certain demographic) by presenting variants of the exponential and logarithmic mathematical functions of various biological and human systems. Smil foresees a battle of the biosphere versus the human material apparatus in the near future. I think intelligent discussion of the contents of this book should be a selection factor for policy makers internationally.

The book is a unique account on growth. Generally, widely know growth studies focus on economic systems and population. However, Mr. Smil book covers also growth trajectories of living matter and human artifacts (e.g. cars, electric generators etc.). Besides description of many growth trajectories, also basics of growth forecasting and linked issues are discussed. Personally, I value this discussions as often fitting techniques are applied blindly, mainly in social sciences, which leads to misunderstanding of reality.As pointed out in other reviews in this book, sometimes, the text is reduced to listing numbers and dates. Although this can be boring for somebody, these parts are highly informative.It seems that the book does not have any particular target audience. In my opinion, it could be attractive for anybody dealing with forecasting, persons interested in history of technology, economists etc. Similarly to wide range of knowlede presented in the book, the audience is also wide.

Brilliant.

I wrongly assumed this book would describe a general, overarching pattern to growth in all areas. But Vaclav Smil doesn't do simple, he does facts.The enormous scope of this book is matched by its wealth of detail. So I recommend you sit in a comfy chair with a hot beverage and your favourite scientific calculator (optional), whilst reading this.And there's no shame in pausing every now and then, to stare into space with your mouth open.

Lindo

Excellente analyse de toutes formes de croissance, avec les impacts positifs et négatifs. Critique sévère de l'actuelle idéologie économique de la croissance sans fin.