Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Black Eyeliner Pencil, Easy to Apply, Smooth Glide, Up to 24 Hour Wear, Onyx, Pack of 2

I have this on Subscribe & Save because I never want to run out of it. I used to buy the much more expensive Estee Lauded eye pencils but this one is just as good. The pewter shade works very well for my brown eyes, not too dark but just right.

I got the brown and it works well for me. I like a natural look. This liner is sharp, glides on smooth and doesn’t tug and my saggy eyes. It lasts hours and doesn’t sweat down my eyes from all my serums and moisturizers. It’s my go to because of the quality and the value.

I have this on reorder. I can never find a good cinnamon color in stores. It’s either too dark or too light. Use this above my upper lash line and it stays all day.

Very Smooth but NOT waterproof.I have very oily skin so Im always trying to find a liner tht WONT smear. I like KAT VON Ds liners but they dry to fast b4 i even get to play with it.I wore this and its doooo easy ti apply. Very milky.l but i noticed after 8 hrs of wear product was missing & smeared. Not crazy bad but noticeable :(Ill keep searching.

Love this eye pencil. Smooth and love the sapphire color. It’s easy to apply and adds to eye emphasis without being overdone. I’m a return buyer for this product.

Best eyeliner I have bought. Smooth application.

Good quality

I don't remember this eyeliner being difficult to apply to the waterline, but it doesn't want to stay in place and requires much rubbing to go on evenly. I'm disappointed because this is something I have used before, and as far as I remember, it was a lot better. Once you rub it a few times, it starts to do its job, but I wish it didn't take so much effort. So far, I have worn it the whole da,y though, and not much has come off. The value for the money is great; I got two for a great price.