Max FactorMasterpiece Max Mascara, Black, 7.2 ml[Amazon-developed Certification] Compact by Design

I have tired so many mascaras and I always go back to this one, it is the absolute best! No, it doesn't give you the super long or dark/bold lashes like other brands BUT it does not smudge/bleed like all the other ones do (I have oily skin so I'm not sure if that's why so many smudge under my bottom lash (I don't apply mascara on my bottom lash either)).The only thing I do not like is that this product comes open, not in a sealed package (it's already open).

The product advertises as "smudge-proof and touch-proof for all day confidence". After a couple months of using it I can say this is not the case. It actually smudges much more than others that do not say are smudge-proof, and it additionally balls-up and makes your eyelashes look messy. This brand is not bad, so it is very surprising this specific product has such low quality.

Love this mascara! Goes on great, lasts all day with no eye irritation no flaking or smudging. I’ve used some every expensive brands that don’t work half as good as this one.

The mascara is a beautiful color and looks really nice next to my light blue eyes. The only problem is that it is not waterproof. The least little bit of moisture and it runs. Other than that, I do like it.

Just okay, doesn't build well.

I've been using this mascara for several years. The only mascara that does not be imprinted on my eyelids and crumbles and does not make eyelashes. This is the best mascara for me.

This is the best mascara I have ever used. It does deliver what it promises. The formula is excellent and the brush really combs through lashes, giving great volume and length. It also defines the eyes very nicely. When Max Factor discontinued in the U.S, I was disappointed. I am so glad that I can now purchase it online. I plan to keep using this mascara because it works very well for me.

This is absolutely my favorite mascara ever, BUT buying online is consistently disappointing (sadly Max Factor discontinued US retail distribution). And this order was one of the worst. It was so dried up I couldn’t even get one good use. I had to add eye drops from day one to make it semi-usable. It seems like they are old/expired, maybe that’s why they don’t come in original packaging (to leave out the expiration date). This is also concerning as it doesn’t seem sanitary. This is the last time I will order online. Was a total waste of money :(