Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara for Stronger, Longer Lashes, Clump-Free, Smudge Proof, Flake-Free, Lengthening Mascara with Olive Oil & Vitamin E Nourishes Eyelashes, Black 02, 0.21 oz

Ive been using this mascara for over 4 yrs. Love the brush it separates lashes really well. Doesnt irritate my eyes. One thing though last order of 2, I received 3 one open I assumed a returned item. I tossed it. But other than that Im very happy with this mascara! I won't buy anywhere else. Best price too!

I’ve tried just about every mascara out there and this one is very good. I don’t wear a lot of makeup anymore- just concealer, blush and mascara so it’s important that what I do wear is worth it. This doesn’t clump or flake and it doesn’t irritate my eyes. It coats your eye lashes well but will not perform any miracles. It works with what you already have. If you have sparse or short eyelashes it won’t make them thick or long.

This is a good mascara for a natural, no makeup makeup look. It doesn't flake badly actually. It adds more volume than lenghth.It was a little dry and chunky when I got it, but adding some rosemary oil helped.And the price is great too!

The delivery was good, Neutrogena is a solid brand and the mascara was good. I probably won't order again as I am going back to old faithful, Lancome or Chanel.

Ok, hear me out. I have always, always (I'm 44) worn the most waterproof mascara you can find. I need it to be sweat proofand cry proof🙃, among my top requirements.I have started noticing over the past few years (no matter what I try) that I get "smudgy" marks under my eyes throughout the day. And we're not talking the sultry, racoon smudges, were talking blotches and circles. I can't stand it. I even stopped wearing mascara on my lower lashes to try and curb this to no avail.After doing a ton of research this product came up as one of the top recommendations. I had to try it.Results: it works (somewhat-ish?). As stated I like very very very waterproof mascara and although I would take the plunge being so desperate, but this is not for me. However, I can do a light sweep on my bottom lashes without hardly any smudging throughout the day. If you are looking for a lightweight, clean mascara this is for you. It does not wear off onto your skin for the most part, however it will rub off at the slightest touch. I feel that once it sets, you almost cannot tell you have any mascara on. I like a little bit more of a glamour-ish look to my mascara and this is definitely not that. If you are looking for clean, natural looking (no makeup look) lashes this is for you.

Easy on, doesn’t flake or smudge, easy to layer. As a contact wearer I started using this mascara years ago. Still my favorite and use it daily. Also, easy to remove.

I know how hard it is to trust a 5 star review. FYI I have tried hundreds of mascaras out there and never have I ever felt consistently good about them after weeks of use. This one, different story! I love it. The brown/black color is beautiful on lashes, it comes off fairly easily, and my eyelashes don't get that crusty feeling with it. I've even forgotten to take it off before and it didn't bother me at all, in fact, I didn't even get itchy eyes from it. This is your sign if you are shopping for a new mascara, get this one!

Does not flake