MAYBELLINETattoo Studio Automatic Gel Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Blendable, Smudge Resistant, Matte Eyeliner For Up To 36HR Wear, Expressotini (Smokey Brown), Packaging May Vary

Best eyeliner I've ever bought. It stays on. Doesn't melt and smear throughout the day. For the most part last all day. I love the thickness and it applies easy. It's really dark without having to reapply several times. LOVE THIS PRODUCT!

This is much better than I had expected! Color quality is deep and goes on easily with a very smooth feel. I primarily use it for my waterline and it takes no work to apply it like many others do. Waterproof and lasts throughout the day, but also comes off easily. Good quality liner and will now be my go-to

I LOVE this eyeliner. Smooth. Glides on. Easy to apply and it lasts all day. Nice jet black. No color fade. Great item Great price.Believe it’s waterproof because I have to wash it off. I haven’t “tested “ it

This is a really great eyeliner. If you're looking for a very durable dark brown gel liner, I would absolutely recommend it - I've been using it for years. One of the only eyeliners or shadows that doesn't transfer to my upper lid, *and* it's fairly easy to take off when you want to remove it. Just water will not work, but I generally remove it with a cloth or in the shower with a small amount of sweet almond oil. It stays all day, unless I rub the outside of my eyes more than a small amount (and that's on me - the only eyeliner I've found that will resist that is MAC liquidlast liner, and that takes some doing to remove and is more of a crisp liquid line). I wouldn't say it would last through a night of sleeping on your side, but it does exactly what I'd want an every day long-lasting liner to do.The only reasons I did 4 starts, and not 5:Grey is more of a light taupe, and brown is quite close to black (I use brown, so I do like it, it's just not as light as it looks on the packaging). Also, I have not had any success at all using the blending end or even my own brushes, so this is not a smokey liner for me in any sense of the word. The line is fairly crisp, just shy of a liquid liner. So if you're looking for a shadow stick to smudge on your lid, I would not recommend this.

I use this pencil for my brows and liner. It works great. Color quality, texture , smudge resistance and being waterproof make this a perfect and versatile piece of eyy makeup.

I can't wear Mascara, so I use eyeliner and no eye irritation and it stays on all day and wipes off with soap and water well. This brown is great for eyebrows. Ilike the smudge end of the liner applicator. goes on easy.

I am on the hunt to find an eyeliner that doesn’t make me look like a raccoon. I had high hopes for this one. Although she does go on incredibly smooth, a lot of it does stay in place all day, & the color is rich. It does still run and smudge, then once she gets on your skin she’s a beast to remove. So on the hunt I continue.

Works great, doesn't budge and goes on so smooth