wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner - Ultra-Fine Brush, Waterproof, 16-Hour Long-Lasting Wear - Cruelty-Free & Vegan - Brown

My first liquid eyeliner! I've had this for a year now and it's still holding up with semi-regular use (I have one other eyeliner that I rotate through). Although the body sometimes detaches, I figured out how to fix it. It got a little dry, but that was just the outside layer of the brush - drawing a little on your hand and shaking the pen fixes that for me. It goes on smooth and doesn't come off after it's set until I wash it, and I have oily skin around my eyes. I also love the brown color as it looks subtle but is still effective.

This eye pen is so fine and easy to control that instead of drawing on one long upper lash line which I always think looks harsh, I draw on tiny diagonal lines, like extra lashes. It looks so much more natural and flattering and reshapes the whole eye. Of course you could just do the regular cat eye stuff as well if your eye is shaped like that (mine isn't.) Once applied it doesn't budge, and the price is right. A perfect eyeliner pen. I just wish it came in more colors.

I've used this product for about 1 month now with no problems.I love the chisel point of this, think calligraphy or highlighter. This makes effortless sharp points on my wings, but it also is quick to fill in the larger areas with just a slight turn of the wrist/pen.I use only waterproof/smudgeproof eyeliners and this product is one of the best! - With a great price point! No smudging, no fadingThat said, I do ALSO always use an eyeshadow primer to give additional longevity to my eyeliners, as I have oily, hooded lids and one eye that weeps a bit more. (See my review for Milani eyeshadow primer for tips.). If it helps you understand this review and my usage, I tend to be more nervous and sporty, not really glitz and glamour. The eyes.. eyeliner, and wings.. is the focus of my makeup with maybe some eyeshadow for color. I want application to be as easy as possible with no touch ups required for the whole day. This item is perfect!Since this one worked out so well, I will try purchasing the other style tips as well.Update: The only downside, I came to buy more "Wing Out" chisel tip eyeliner pens and they don't have them available anymore?! :(

I love the actual product, but the cap keeps falling off and it dries up because of that. I’ve bought this product three times before but the same thing keeps happening. Besides that, I think the color is nice, the application is easy, and I love how thin it is. I just wish the cap stayed on a little better to stop people like me from running into this problem.

very smooth and does last me all day. I love the fine point of the applicator tip. It makes it very easy to get a smaller eyeliner look. Easy to make wings. Dries quickly and doesn't smudge. Dark bold color and application is super easy. GREAT quality for price.

Great eyeliner one of my favorite ones. I have it 3 stars because the top pops off and makes eyeliner dry out, I've put tape to hold it even placed it inside a bag but the hassle of all that is just not worth it. Sadly I changed eyeliners.

10/10 recommend this product. Lasts forever. Pigmented. Easy to put on. Beautifully clean cut lines. Was so surprised on how this stuff is for the price — now I buy nothing else.

Nice liner...non irritating once it's dry. Don't let it drip into your eyes, it'll burn. Stays on all day. Easy to apply. I store it in a cup, brush side down so it's always loaded with product.